Bureau of Investigation: Investigations in Arkham & Elsewhere

TATaha Afyounistar4.6

Our group has completed and loved all 4 Sherlock Holmes Consulting Detective boxes, so this was a guaranteed purchase for us. Overall, it was a good experience, but the stories aren't as captivating as the ones in SHCD. Also, we're not too familiar with the Cthulhu universe, so we sometimes struggled with the leaps of logic. However, we did appreciate how different each case felt! Our scores: Case 1 - 6/7 points (An okay case, but not too memorable or interesting.) Case 2 - 7/7 points (Most similar case to SHCD, and probably our favorite.) Case 3 - 7/7 points (Very creative case but we felt stuck several times.) Case 4 - N/A (We liked the case as it was unique, but what to do at the end was unclear.) Case 5 - 7/7 points (While we figured this one out pretty quickly, the story was one of the weakest.) If I had to rank them, it would be case 2 > 4 > 5 > 3 > 1.