Sherlock Holmes Consulting Detective: The Baker Street Irregulars

Play as members of Holmes’ network of street children, investigating criminal cases across Victorian London. This cooperative deduction game sends players through the city to gather clues, interview witnesses, and piece together timelines to answer case-specific questions and compare results with the master detective’s solutions. The standalone set contains ten scenarios, including introductory cases for new players and more complex mysteries that introduce new mechanics and twists for experienced investigators.

Players: 1–8 best 2
Playing time: 90 min
Age: 14+
Complexity: 2.3 / 5

8.7 on LudoyaDeductionMurder / MysteryCooperative GameNarrative Choice / ParagraphStorytelling

Play it with Ludoya

About the game

Design: Dave Neale
Art: Pascal Quidault
Neriac
Arnaud Demaegd
Bernard Bittler
Publisher: Space Cowboys

Plays with

See them in Ludoya

Sherlock Holmes Consulting Detective: The Thames Murders & Other Cases1981

Sherlock Holmes Consulting Detective: Jack the Ripper & West End Adventures2016

Sherlock Holmes Consulting Detective: Carlton House & Queen's Park2017

Sherlock Holmes Consulting Detective: An Irregular Meeting2020

Photos from Ludoya tables

All photos in Ludoya

On Ludoya's tables

Full stats in Ludoya

85
Plays logged: 34
Players: 1h 32m
Average play: 67
In collections: 12
On wishlists

8.7/10

from 11 Ludoya reviews

Taha Afyouni10.0
If you haven't tried any Sherlock Holmes Consulting Detective game, I would recommend starting with this one! It's excellently written, and a bit easier than the rest of the boxes.
Played it 11 times
the-fire-archmage-ninja10.0
Fuck Sherlock Holmes
Played it 10 times